Mamá Maggie's Kitchen
menu icon
search icon

25 Bake Sale Recipes That’ll Earn Big Bucks

Published: by

This collection of bake sale recipes is packed with easy, crowd-pleasing treats for any occasion. From classic cookies and bars to muffins, scones, and no-bake sweets, there’s something for everyone. Whether you want a nostalgic favorite or a creative new recipe, these desserts are simple to make and full of flavor. Perfect for bake sales, family get-togethers, or just a sweet homemade treat!

This post may include affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Cookie Dough Bars

A batch of chocolate-covered cookie dough bars is displayed on parchment paper. One bar is tilted, resting on a few others, revealing a thick chocolate layer on top and a chunky cookie dough layer with chocolate chips. Sea salt is sprinkled on top.
Cookie Dough Bars. Photo credit: Living Chirpy.

These cookie dough bars, made with almond flour, offer a healthier twist on regular cookies. They’re a tasty, guilt-free snack!
Get Recipe: Cookie Dough Bars

Strawberry Cream Cheese Pastry

Strawberry Cream Cheese Pastry served on a white plate.

Savor the deliciousness of a strawberry cream cheese pastry. With a flaky, golden crust and creamy strawberry filling, it’s a perfect choice for breakfast or dessert.
Get Recipe: Strawberry Cream Cheese Pastry

Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies

A close-up of chocolate cookies on a wire rack. One cookie stands out with a beautifully piped, swirl-patterned caramel-colored frosting on top. The cookies have a rich, dark brown color and the wooden table underneath slightly shows through the rack.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies. Photo credit: Cooking with Carlee.

Soft chocolate whoopie pies are stuffed with a peanut butter marshmallow filling. Made with cake mix, they’re a fun and easy treat to whip up!
Get Recipe: Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies

Pan de Polvo (Shortbread Cookies)

A pile of pan de polvo cookies on a wooden platform.

Pan de Polvo cookies are soft and coated in a sweet cinnamon-sugar mix. Their warm, spiced flavor makes them perfect for chilly winter days.
Get the recipe: Pan de Polvo

Cream Cheese Brownies

A close-up of a decadent chocolate marble brownie, featuring a rich, fudgy base swirled with creamy white chocolate on top. The swirls create a visually appealing, intricate pattern. The brownie appears moist and dense, promising a delicious treat.
Cream Cheese Brownies. Photo credit: Small Town Woman.

Fudgy chocolate brownies with a rich cheesecake swirl make these cream cheese brownies a dessert everyone will love.
Get Recipe: Cream Cheese Brownies

Pumpkin Empanadas

A white plate filled with pumpkin empanadas sits on a red and white patterned cloth. Cinnamon sticks are placed beside the plate, and an orange pumpkin and flowers are in the background, giving a cozy, autumnal feel to the scene.

Empanadas de Calabaza, or Pumpkin Empanadas, are a classic Mexican fall treat with a sweet, spiced pumpkin filling. A must-try!
Get the recipe: Pumpkin Empanadas

Gooey Brownies

A batch of rich, fudgy brownies with chunks of chocolate and a sprinkling of sea salt on top is arranged on a white parchment paper. A small bowl of chocolate pieces and a jar of milk are nearby, suggesting a perfect pairing for this indulgent treat.
Gooey Brownies. Photo credit: Sweet Fix Baker.

These gooey brownies are the fudgiest, softest, and easiest ones you’ll ever make—perfect for serious chocolate cravings.
Get Recipe: Gooey Brownies

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bread

Pumpkin Chocolate Chipe Bread sliced and on a cooling rack.

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bread is a fall favorite that everyone looks forward to each year. A warm slice on a chilly morning is pure comfort.
Get the recipe: Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bread

Double Chocolate Paw Print Cookies

A close-up of eight chocolate cookies shaped like bear paws with large chocolate discs in the center and several smaller chocolate chips positioned as toes. The cookies are arranged on a white surface.
Double Chocolate Paw Print Cookies. Photo credit: Cooking with Carlee.

Double chocolate paw print cookies are soft, chewy chocolate treats topped with cute chocolate paw prints. Both adorable and delicious!
Get Recipe: Double Chocolate Paw Print Cookies

Hojarascas (Mexican Shortbread Cookies)

A close-up of Mexican shortbread cookies on a gold, round plate.
Hojarascas. Photo credit: Mama Maggie’s Kitchen.

Enjoy the sweet taste of Hojarascas—Mexican cookies coated in cinnamon sugar. They’re so tasty, you’ll want to keep coming back for more.
Get the recipe: Hojarascas

Copycat Lofthouse Cookies

Colorful sugar cookies are topped with bright pink frosting and a variety of colorful round sprinkles. The cookies are close together, showcasing their vibrant decoration and rich, creamy frosting on a light-colored surface.
Copycat Lofthouse Cookies. Photo credit: Recipes from a Pantry.

Soft and fluffy, these copycat Lofthouse cookies have creamy frosting and colorful sprinkles—just like the ones from the bakery!
Get Recipe: Copycat Lofthouse Cookies

Panqué de Nuez (Pecan Pound Cake)

A loaf of banana bread on a wooden cutting board, topped with caramel drizzle and chopped nuts. Two slices are cut and placed in front of the loaf, revealing a moist interior with visible nut pieces.

Panqué de Nuez is a moist, buttery cake flavored with nuts and cinnamon. It’s drizzled with Mexican caramel and sprinkled with pecans—an irresistible treat!
Get Recipe: Panqué de nuez

Easy 2-Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge

A close-up image of multiple pieces of caramel fudge arranged in a grid pattern. The pieces are mostly triangular, with a creamy texture, and some are sprinkled with coarse sea salt. The fudge's rich caramel color contrasts against the scattered salt crystals.
Easy 2-Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge. Photo credit: Sweet Fix Baker.

This 2-ingredient peanut butter fudge is as easy as it gets—quick, sweet, and perfect for peanut butter fans.
Get Recipe: Easy 2-Ingredient Peanut Butter Fudge

Pecan Praline Cookies

A top-down view of a white table with a plate of cookies, some with bites taken out, and a couple of cups of coffee in green saucers. A cooling rack with more cookies and pink-striped napkins are also visible. The cookies are nut-studded and arranged neatly.
Pecan Praline Cookies. Photo credit: Little Black Skillet.

Chewy pecan praline cookies combine the rich, buttery taste of Southern praline candy with the perfect cookie texture.
Get Recipe: Pecan Praline Cookies

Lemon Sugar Cookies

Top view of a white plate containing three lemon cookies, with four lemon slices arranged around them. A couple of whole lemons and lemon slices are placed beside the plate on a white surface.
Lemon Sugar Cookies. Photo credit: Live To Sweet.

Lemon sugar cookies are crispy on the edges, soft in the center, and packed with fresh lemon flavor. A simple, bright treat!
Get Recipe: Lemon Sugar Cookies

Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Treats

A top view of crunchy peanut butter rice krispie treats are cut into squares and placed on a wooden surface. Some of the squares are drizzled with white icing. The treats have a golden, crispy appearance with a slightly uneven texture.
Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Treats. Photo credit: Dizzy Busy & Hungry.

Peanut butter rice krispie treats add a salty, nutty twist to the classic crispy dessert. Super easy to make and always a hit!
Get Recipe: Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Treats

Zucchini Bars

Two pieces of chewy oat and nut bars stacked on top of each other, drizzled with white icing. The bars are golden-brown with a texture indicating rolled oats and crushed nuts. The background is blurred, highlighting the focus on the dessert.
Zucchini Bars. Photo credit: The Dizzy Cook.

Gooey oat zucchini bars are topped with a sweet cream cheese drizzle, making them a unique and delicious treat.
Get Recipe: Zucchini Bars

Easy No Bake Oreo Bars

A baking tray holds several chocolate scones drizzled with white icing. The tray is partially lined with a red and white polka dot cloth at one corner. The scones are arranged in rows, creating a visually appealing and tasty display.
Easy No Bake Oreo Bars. Photo credit: DIY & Fun.

These no-bake Oreo bars come together in just 10 minutes with only four ingredients, making them the perfect quick chocolatey treat and a favorite of all bake sale recipes.

Get Recipe: Easy No Bake Oreo Bars

Giant Cookie

Three triangular slices of a large cookie topped with colorful candies and drizzled with chocolate, resting on a cooling rack. The background features a partially visible patterned sheet and the word "GIANT" in green text to the left.
Giant Cookie. Photo credit: Healing Tomato.

This giant cookie is a fun, oversized dessert that can be made vegan or vegetarian. Great for Christmas or any special occasion!
Get Recipe: Giant Cookie

Banana Biscoff Cake

An overhead view of three beige, square-shaped frosted cakes, each topped with a large swirl of frosting, a sandwich cookie, and small white flowers. One slice is missing from the cake in the center, revealing layers within. Crumbs are scattered around.
Banana Biscoff Cake. Photo credit: Oh My Veg.

Moist banana cake is layered with rich Biscoff buttercream, blending banana and caramelized cookie flavors into one amazing dessert.
Get Recipe: Banana Biscoff Cake

Easy Lemon Butterfly Cakes

A close-up of a butterfly cake in a yellow paper cup. The golden-brown cupcake is topped with a swirl of yellow buttercream frosting and two triangular pieces of sponge cake arranged to resemble butterfly wings. The frosting is dusted with powdered sugar.
Easy Lemon Butterfly Cakes. Photo credit: Eat Cook Bake.

These classic British butterfly cakes are topped with a swirl of lemon buttercream, adding a fancy, sweet touch to any celebration.
Get Recipe: Easy Lemon Butterfly Cakes

Speculoos Cookies

A close-up of Christmas-themed cookies shaped like a snowman and a Christmas tree leaning against a festive holiday tin decorated with bells, holly, and gifts. The background includes a partially visible orange.
Speculoos Cookies. Photo credit: My Chef’s Apron.

These spiced Belgian/Dutch Speculoos cookies bring warmth and holiday cheer to your dessert table. Classic, simple, and delicious!
Get Recipe: Speculoos Cookies

Buttery Buckwheat Chocolate Chip Cookies

A batch of chocolate chip cookies sits on parchment paper in a white box against a blue background. Some cookies are laid out next to the box with one broken in half. A glass of milk stands nearby.
Buttery Buckwheat Chocolate Chip Cookies. Photo credit: My Chef’s Apron.

Buckwheat chocolate chip cookies are warm and spiced, with a chewy middle and a crisp edge. Simply irresistible and a great addition to your collection of bake sale recipes.
Get Recipe: Buttery Buckwheat Chocolate Chip Cookies

Easy White Chocolate Raspberry Scones

A top-down view of several freshly baked raspberry white chocolate scones drizzled with glaze, placed on a white background. A bowl of fresh raspberries is visible in the upper right corner. The scones have a golden-brown crust with visible raspberry and white chocolate chunks.
Easy White Chocolate Raspberry Scones. Photo credit: The Fresh Cooky.

White chocolate raspberry scones are tender, sweet, and a little tart, with chunks of white chocolate and juicy raspberries in every bite.
Get Recipe: Easy White Chocolate Raspberry Scones

Peach Coffee Cake Muffins

A close-up image of a single muffin on a dark blue plate with a reflective surface. The muffin is topped with powdered sugar and crumbly bits, with its wrapper displaying a patriotic theme of stars and stripes in red, white, and blue.
Peach Coffee Cake Muffins. Photo credit: Family Around The Table.

Peach coffee cake muffins are packed with juicy peaches and topped with a crunchy cinnamon streusel. A treat that works any time of day!
Get Recipe: Peach Coffee Cake Muffins

More Recipe Roundups

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *